• What started it all!

  1. Slide 1
  2. Slide 2
  3. Slide 3
  4. Slide 4
  5. Slide 5

Never had Ted's pepper butter before?

Delivery to Athens!

We now deliver to the Athens area! All Ted's Pepper Butter ordered for delivery between Wednesday and Tuesday will be delivered the following Wednesday. All memorabilia will still have to ship. Just choose delivery at checkout.


If you buy $50 of Pepper Butter you can receive any $10 item for free! Just pay shipping. This includes another jar of Ted's Pepper Butter or MEMORABILIA!!

Everything tastes better with

Ohio Proud

More ino

Adrianna Hammond

Guy was super friendly! My husband loves the original, and I'm in love with the sweet!. It's not like every other pepper butter it's so good.

Keisha Laverack Smith

I am in love with this stuff. I have used it on everything since I got it and I will be getting lots more!

Mary J Perry

It is very good, we use it on everything. I would highly recommend it!

Riley Spencer

We got some at Rockbridge today and it was awesome! All the different kinds are all good, we bought the sweet kind and we can’t stop eating it. Even the baby loves it 😂We’re gonna buy all the other ones!

Jeff Neel

Took it to work today and it’s a pretty big hit I’m gonna need more!

Why We Do What We Do!

Over 30 years ago my parents were given a pepper butter recipe. To this day I can't remember if it was from a cook book or from the Amish country in northern Ohio.  Nevertheless we enjoyed it but, they felt that it could be better. So, they began making changes to it over the next several years till it became their own perfected pepper butter recipe. My father continued making it for family and friends a couple of times each year till it became somewhat known in the Athens area.  When he passed I decided that we needed to not only carry on his recipe, because it is so amazing, but also to carry on his memory.  That is why every jar has him on it and the love for him in it.  His pepper butter was and is so delicious that we had to make sure that everyone got to enjoy it.  So, since not everyone likes spicy things and some like it a little hotter we took his recipe and made some with bell pepper so that you get all of the flavor with none of the heat and another with jalapenos so that it would satisfy the other side. Once you pop open and try it you won't stop thinking what else can I put this on! 

Gift card

Looking for something for someone special? A gift card to our store is the perfect idea!

order here!

Pepper Butter



Phone cases

Tote bags

All Memorabilia

Hocking Hills Flea Market

26792 US Highway 33, Rockbridge, Ohio 43149


Saturdays 10 - 5

Sundays 10 - 4

Get directions